Vernetzen Sie sich mit uns


EU-Russland: Zerstörung als Schöpfung




AGyMzDW-360The EU’s ‘restrictive measures’ as an answer to Crimea and Sevastopol entering the Russian Federation included the closure of paramount communication channels, such as the EU-Russia Summits and visa ban for 33 influential figures – measures leaving little hope of a negotiated outcome to the Ukrainian crisis. On such a reduced communication level, how to exchange views to reach rapprochement?

The very concept of a ‘black list’ as a tool to influence Russian policy was pioneered by the EU in the context of the notorious Magnitsky case, when his former employer Bill Browder pointed to the Achilles heel of Russian corrupt officials allegedly responsible for Sergei Magnitsky’s death  – unlike the Communists, ‘new Russians’ enjoy the acquisition of property, recreation, sightseeing, shopping, in brief, having a good time in Europe.

Therefore, the ban on entry and freezing assets can be an effective measure in creating discomfort for corrupt lovers of luxury. The European Parliament discussed and compiled various lists, targeting officials to enhance an objective investigation into Magnistky’s murder in a prison cell. Although the MEPs’ initiative enshrined in a Resolution didn’t reach further instance, namely the Council, the experience remained vivid.

Allerdings ist der Entwurf der gezielten Maßnahmen im Magnitski Fall mechanisch in den oberen Figuren in der russischen politischen "beau monde" in der ukrainischen Krise reagieren, die beredtes Beispiel für die Begrenzung der Komparatistik - man kann nicht die unvergleichliche verwirren. Wenn in der Magnitski Affäre wurden die Visa-Verbote für die Persönlichkeiten auferlegt, die niemand, die einflussreichen russischen Beamten in der ukrainischen Krise sprechen wollte, die in der politischen Debatte teilgenommen haben sollen, wurden ausgeschlossen. Ein völlig kontraproduktiv bewegen!

The 33-list was officially brought into the picture via an initiative from High Representative Catherine Ashton. It includes people who, according to the establishment she leads, are responsible for “undermining and threatening the territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence” of Ukraine, an approach shielding the individual member states against Russian ire. According to European diplomats, the proposals of the black-list personalities behind these initiatives are ‘sensitive’ information and shall not be disclosed. One can only guess which countries put forward the idea of banning EU entry to the speaker of the Russian Duma, Sergei Naryshkin, a gesture to champion the most shortsighted move in the history of diplomacy.

This is the very same Naryshkin whose refusal to come to the Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly (PACE), under the pretext of its ‘Russophobic’ tendencies, caused “disappointment” for its president Jean-Claude Mignon, who expressed his regret, saying “it takes two to hold a dialogue”. Much ink was spilled to put the speaker to shame, blaming him for an attempt to avoid the questions of 65 European legislators in the assembly, who listed the questions to their Russian counterpart. Naryshkin faced accusations of boycott and negligence of his prime responsibility of keeping up communications with the international communit – his high public status does not allow him to remain silent.

Now, the EU ‘blacklist’ has been enlarged with the names of the Duma’s other prominent members, and even the head of the state news agency Russia Today.


Ähnliche Status Persönlichkeiten aus in ein Land verboten als heftige Offensive auf die Demokratie und die Rechtsstaatlichkeit durch den Westen würde gesehen, wie Parlamente und die Presse als Säulen der Demokratie definiert sind.

The current bans on 33 are limited to half a year, under the EU’s monitoring conditions, but  irrespective of further collisions the damage done to the co-operation of East and West will last much longer than six months. However, the passion for destruction of Ashton’s diplomats can be understood by Russians – as their own anarchist philosopher Bakunin claimed “destruction is creation”.


Anna van Densky

Teile diesen Artikel:

EU Reporter veröffentlicht Artikel aus einer Vielzahl externer Quellen, die ein breites Spektrum an Standpunkten zum Ausdruck bringen. Die in diesen Artikeln vertretenen Positionen sind nicht unbedingt die von EU Reporter.